Oil Tank Route.Heating oil · Tank tools · Records

Fuel comparison · Reviewed November 18, 2026

Heating Oil vs. Propane: Cost per Useful Heat Calculator

Compare heating oil and propane by cost per million Btu of useful heat. Enter both quoted prices and equipment efficiencies to find a break-even propane price.

The quick answer

Compare useful heat rather than gallons. Using EIA sample conversion factors, a gallon of heating oil contains about 138,500 Btu and propane about 91,452 Btu. Divide each fuel price by its energy content and equipment efficiency to compare operating fuel costs on the same basis.

Compare fuel cost per useful heat

Example: oil $42.47 and propane $36.45 per useful million Btu. Break-even propane price: $3.496/gallon.

Defaults are an illustrative scenario. The calculation uses 138,500 Btu/gallon oil and 91,452 Btu/gallon propane. Taxes, delivery fees, tank rental and equipment conversion costs are excluded; compare those separately.

Why the lower per-gallon price may not win

One gallon of propane and one gallon of heating oil do not represent the same energy. At equal efficiency, the conversion factors used here give roughly 1.514 gallons of propane for the energy in one gallon of oil. Different equipment efficiencies change the useful heat delivered from either purchase.

This calculator compares a fuel-cost component. It does not estimate a complete conversion project, installation cost, tank rental, financing or maintenance. Keep those items separate when evaluating whether to change equipment.

The useful-heat calculation

Useful million Btu per gallon = Btu per gallon × efficiency as a decimal ÷ 1,000,000. Cost per useful million Btu = price per gallon ÷ useful million Btu per gallon. Enter an equipment-specific seasonal efficiency assumption; an input of 85% means 0.85 in the formula.

For a hypothetical oil price of $5.00 and 85% efficiency, useful heat per gallon is 0.117725 million Btu. The cost is about $42.47 per useful million Btu. For propane at $3.00 and 90% efficiency, useful heat is 0.0823068 million Btu per gallon and the cost is about $36.45. Those efficiencies and prices are illustrative, not defaults proven for your home.

Find the propane price that matches oil

Break-even propane price = oil price × (propane Btu × propane efficiency) ÷ (oil Btu × oil efficiency). With the same $5.00 oil, 85% oil and 90% propane assumptions, the break-even propane price is about $3.496 per gallon. Below that, propane has a lower fuel cost per useful heat under these inputs; above it, oil does.

This relationship is useful when a supplier gives a propane quote. It lets you compare that quote to your oil price while keeping the efficiency assumptions visible, instead of treating every dollar-per-gallon difference as a saving.

Use comparable prices and equipment assumptions

A fuel price can vary with purchase quantity, payment terms or delivery area. Add relevant recurring charges to the comparison period separately. If propane has a tank rental or minimum-use fee, a low unit price alone will not show its annual effect.

  • Use local quotes for the same period, with each fuel's correct delivery terms.
  • Check tax and fee treatment instead of silently mixing included and excluded charges.
  • Use a documented efficiency assumption for each appliance; label uncertainty.
  • Compare several plausible prices and efficiencies rather than treating the example as a forecast.
  • Keep a full conversion quote separate from this fuel-only calculation.

Turn the unit comparison into an annual scenario

If your scenario needs 60 million Btu of useful heat, multiply each calculated unit cost by 60. The illustrative figures above give about $2,548 for oil and $2,187 for propane before excluded charges. The 60-million-Btu requirement is an assumed equal heat demand, not a measured average or a prediction for your property.

To make this personal, start with reliable delivery history and equipment information. Fuel-cost savings alone cannot establish the payback of new equipment without installation, recurring costs and an honest range for future fuel use.

Sources and calculation notes

Editorial review: November 18, 2026. Supplier examples illustrate published terms; confirm the current offer directly. All worked-price and consumption scenarios are labeled assumptions. Price data, when shown, has its own observation and release date.

Prepared by Oil Tank Route. We publish independent planning tools and do not accept fuel orders.